By /

🎓 What Colleges Really Mean When They Say “Holistic Admissions”

Let’s talk about a word you’ll hear a lot this season: holistic.

Colleges love to use it—especially when parents ask if GPA or test scores will make or break an application. But here’s the thing: what they say and what actually happens aren’t always the same.

📚 A Real-World Story (That Might Sound Familiar)

My daughter’s best friend was considering the Honors College at Ole Miss. When they visited, the admissions rep reassured her: “Don’t worry—we take a holistic approach. We look at the whole student.”

That sounded hopeful. She had a 27 on the ACT, solid grades, and strong extracurriculars. But when we went home and looked closer, something didn’t sit right.

The average ACT score for admitted Honors students? Over 30. Average GPA? North of 3.5. Holistic or not, the numbers told a clearer story: this program was likely out of reach without higher stats.

That’s the part families often miss. Colleges can say they’re holistic—and many truly do consider more than scores—but at certain levels (especially competitive programs or honors colleges), the bar is still academic first. And if your student doesn’t end up in the Honors program? That doesn’t mean they don’t belong—it just means there are other ways to stand out and thrive.

🔍 So What Is Holistic Admissions—Really?

At its core, it means colleges consider more than just GPA and test scores. They evaluate your student’s whole story—academics, extracurriculars, personal context, and more—to understand them fully. But as we’ve seen, some parts of that story still carry more weight than others.

📋 What They’re Actually Looking At

  • Transcript rigor: Did your student take challenging classes available at their school?
  • Class rank: Where does your student stand compared to classmates?
  • Test scores: Still considered, even at test-optional schools.
  • Personal essays: A critical chance to showcase personality, values, and resilience.
  • Activities/Brag sheet: How your student spends their time outside class.
  • Letters of recommendation: Personal endorsements from teachers and mentors.
  • Context: First-generation status, economic background, personal hardships, or unique family circumstances.

❓ Do Test-Optional Colleges Still Look at Scores?

Yes—if your student submits test scores, colleges will consider them. \”Test-optional\” does not mean \”test-blind.\” Schools will still evaluate strong test scores favorably but won’t penalize students who don’t submit them.

🎯 What This Means for Your Student

Holistic admissions gives your student a chance to shine even if they aren’t perfect academically. Here’s how to make the most of it:

  • Highlight strengths clearly through essays and brag sheets.
  • Provide context in the Common App’s additional information section if relevant.
  • Select recommenders who know your student deeply and can vouch for their character and determination.

💡 FAQs

Will submitting test scores help or hurt?
Submit them if they’re at or above a college’s average; skip them if they’re significantly below.

How much do essays really matter?
Essays often tip the scales in admissions—colleges want students who fit their campus culture and have clear motivations.

Is it bad if your kid doesn’t have a leadership title?
Not at all. Colleges value commitment, growth, and meaningful involvement over titles alone.

Can strong letters offset a weaker GPA?
They definitely can help by highlighting your student’s strengths beyond grades alone, especially for borderline applicants.

✅ What to Do Next

Scroll to Top